Cheating is VERY personal.
No - not that kind - the kind where we go off the food plan!
Let’s address the term first - “cheating” sounds kinda harsh. You’re not trolling Ashley Madison; you’re eating a donut. Or a piece of pizza. Or whatever you’re not ‘supposed’ to be :). You’ve wandered off-plan. I’m using ‘cheating’ for brevity :).
There are a number of different KINDS of cheating and cheaters.
The “Optimist Cheater” - this is the person who each day arises with a new reserve of willpower, determined to eat the bare minimum the food plan requires, like they’re cramming for an exam (because a weigh-in is often around the corner.) And by 5pm or whenever that last straw of stress falls on your back, and the kids are fighting in the back of the minivan and you’ve calculated that you can just barely beat the Papa John’s driver home if you call the order in NOW, you’re done. Lather, rinse, repeat. Sadly, this is the most destructive kind of cheating, because having been in a state of famine much of the day, AND nearing bedtime, the body very efficiently processes and stores the extra calories, not knowing when it may be fed again.
The “Hostess Cheater” can’t stand the idea of making those around them uncomfortable by not eating everything they are. Never mind that no one will notice you skipped the mashed potatoes. It’s the office birthday party sheet cake and no one will care if you don’t have a piece (except the person who was raised not to “waste food” and will take it home.) If you’re THAT person, it may be helpful to consider that cake isn’t really food - it’s closer to a delivery device for the drug “sugar.”
The “Tag Team” cheater - these are the people who are supposed to serve as accountabilibuddies, keeping each other on track. Maybe they’re office mates or a couple, but when one folds, he or she takes the other one down, too. Guilt shared is not actually guilt halved. Sometimes you can’t save both of you, but you’re not obliged to go down with the ship.
The “Oops Cheater” - how did THAT get in my mouth? It just happened! Better to acknowledge the choice that we make in putting in there - not as an exercise in penance, but in asserting our control.
This is a close cousin to the “Unplanned Cheat Cheater” - this person believes they fell into a cheat, but it was more likely a failure to plan NOT to cheat.
The “Secret Cheater” - this person is the most concerning to me - disordered eating is a diagnosis beyond my scope of practice to make, but if you cheat in secret, or binge eat, that’s a potentially serious problem that you may want to consider discussing. I recommend logging specifics of cheat meals for all clients; facing our food is a big first step to shaking its hold over us.
Look for patterns in your forays off-plan. Guilt is a massively useless emotion - it happens after the transgression and rarely affects the decision to commit the next one. How can we set ourselves up for success each and every day?
All the best,
Marcey
Coach Marcey Tidwell started as a client with NGPT in January 2011. Joining the team as an accountability coach, she wears many hats in assisting the Meltdown Nation! Nurse Marcey by day, she brings a wealth of knowledge the program! She believes that we control far more of our lives and choices than we usually like to admit :).






Over the last 2 years, I had slowly gained over 50 pounds. More than it being a vanity thing, I was having trouble doing basic tasks that came easy to me just a few years before, like putting my socks on, walking up the hill to Bloomingfoods on 2nd street, and keeping up on bike rides with my friends. My strength, flexibility, and cardiovascular health had declined in a major way from bad habits. I was eating horribly and drinking way more than necessary. I wanted so badly to re-establish good habits to ensure a healthy future for myself and whatever family I may one day have. I had tried many times to make a change on my own to no avail. A Facebook friend had been posting about his success and major weight loss with NGPT. I was intrigued and impressed, so I decided to look into it.